Tuesday, 13 March 2012

In The News This Week...


My attention was drawn this morning to an article on the news this morning about 40K.  So much so, that I've decided to take a post to consider it.  It's available here.  For those readers outside the UK, the BBC is a socialist propaganda website, sworn to overthrow the current world order and enslave humanity.  For those readers inside the UK, I suggest you stop paying your licence fee in protest.

Anyway, enough about the site.  The article (belligerently entitled: Why are adults still launching tabletop war?) was basically one journalist's disbelief that adults could still be drawn into what was effectively toy soldiers.  It was a bit demeaning to have all your life's passion derided as 'toys' or 'figurines', like it's some porcelain Victorian doll rather than a lumbering behemoth of a Leman Russ with heavy bolters and lascannon and battle cannons blazing ...



Anyway, the article aside, it did get me thinking about wargaming in general, and the 40K hobby.  In my circle of friends I'm probably the most avid 40K gamer: I regularly spend upwards of £30-40 on 'Collectors' models, I've probably pumped about £500 into Forgeworld over the years, and I loyally stick to Citadel paints and brushes.

Why?

Well, I suppose the simplest excuse is that it's what I grew up on.  About 10 years ago, on a family trip to Cleethorpes I spent most of the day eagerly drooling over a borrowed, dog-eared copy of the Third Edition Rulebook.  And I was hooked.  In those days it was easier to start, as the models were a darn sight cheaper.  (As an aside, on that grey September morn it was the photos of the Mordian Iron Guard that I truly fell in love with, hence my enthusiasm at finally, a decade on, being close to finishing a Mordian army).

Nowadays, 40K does have a lot going for it.  I often say that, in my experience of modelling supplies they do the best-quality products.  This is no longer true, with the advent of the Perry Brothers' fine plastic kits for example, the GW monopoly is starting to slip in this and other fields.  They are still very visually impressive and have a long legacy of fluff, battle reports, White Dwarfs, and now even books and games, into which you can delve and immerse yourself.

But there are the downsides.  The rules are clunky and unusable; driven by a pathogenic impulsion to do a glorious re-release every few years, the rules have to be extensively re-written when there's no strong need to do so.  So much, in fact, that we now play a version of 40K mainly based on 4th Ed and a mental cocktail of the few sweet spots in the new rules, with a healthy dose of house rules.  But by far the most common slating of 40K is the price, and rightly so.  40K prices (and Warhammer, for that matter), have been in an explosive upwards spiral for many years now.  Coupled with the advent of such games as Apocolypse, it's now only possible to afford a 'normal sized' game by being Bonnie and/or Clyde.

And yet we game on.  I started this article with a view to answering this dichotomy once and for all, but it hasn't turned out that way.  I love the rules, I suppose.  Or at least, the rules as me and my friends have modified them.  I love the painting ... well, I love painting - doing it myself.  I love the background, or at least the background that I created for my army ... and that might just be it.  We don't play '40K' ... we make the hobby our own, and price can be no barrier to that.  Out of the box, it may not have any appeal any more, but we aren't just 'buying the latest model'.  We're feeding many enjoyable years of playing the hobby, which is why we still find it worthwhile.  Interestingly, they had Mark Wells (CEO) defending price hikes, saying "it's not what we do".

Well, it is, but I'm still going to finish the Mordian army.

8 comments:

  1. A superb post, I nearly did a post of my own on this but you've done it far better. the crux of it is I would be a more avid 40k gamer if I could afford to be, as it stands I simply can't. Although I would say that I perhaps consume the most fluff (despite not liking much of the BL stuff) and that's what I love about the setting, even if I don't like the simplification of its current direction. But as you say, we do have the liberty to change that - we're lucky to have a gaming group (as it were) where these things and changes are possible, where we can play smaller games; what I hear from others is that many can't do that unfortunately. But as it stands I wholeheartedly agree with the post, I've been gaming 40k since '96 and have very fond memories of huge, carpet-based clashes that would be interrupted by the cat strolling through - no blast templates needed there.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You're right, it's about having a group of like minded individuals. As long as you agree, you can't avoid having fun - I'm sure all the loud spotty teenagers who play the game nowadays enjoy it as much as we do, albeit on a very different level.

      Ah, the perils of the Cat of Doom, and the Mum Coming In To Hoover on a 4+ after turn 6 ... those were the days! *Misty-eyed nostalgia*

      Delete
    2. The in-store games do seem a bit sterile now, and I know from speaking to staff doing everything "by the book" is encouraged, I remember a fantastic 8 a side game in which everyone brought a squad or two and my side (I had my Nurgle Plague Marines) had to kill the enemy psyker in the tower at the other end of the board and the Eldar, Guard and Marines had to stop us. We blew up the Tower - subtlety all the way. I hope games like that still happen, and as long as there is still a degree of encouraging creativity, then GW hasn't lost what I loved about it.

      Delete
  2. Good article. I started buying GW Products way back in the 80's, before hicks in the metal prices, before before 'finecast', in fact before the first plastics! Prices certainly have increased since those days I can assure you!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Wow, that just goes to show there's always someone who's been doing it longer than you have ... actually Warhammer started before I was born so the good ol' days to which you refer predate me a little bit. Scary thought! Thanks for the feedback.

      Delete
    2. You're making me feel old now...

      Delete
  3. Great article - thanks.

    I absolutely shudder at the prospect of trying to get into this hobby today mind. As it is, just about the only thing that keeps me thinking about it so frequently is the excellent club to which I belong.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for the comment. You're right, the only thing that keeps us going is the mates we have from the hobby over the years rather than the game itself.

      Delete